The architecture of the buildings, mausoleums, and larger monuments in a cemetery such as Crown Hill most often displays influences from Classical, Romanesque, Gothic, Egyptian, or some form of more modern architecture. Crown Hill has examples of each influence, especially the classical. This makes it a very handy site at which to study the history of Western Architecture.
Classical
Modeled
after Greek and Roman temples, with their many columns, pediments, and
strong symmetry, buildings in the classical style were very popular
throughout the 1800s. Contemporary excavations of Roman ruins such as
Pompeii increased this influence. It predominates in cemeteries from the
era, despite being criticized by some Christian leaders who wanted
monuments which reminded them of the resurrection: "To the mourners of
pagan antiquity, death was extinction." But simple beauty seems to have
won out over complicated symbolism.
Numerous examples of the classical influence are all around Crown Hill. A walk to the top of the hill provides the opportunity to show Doric, Ionic, and Corinthian columns almost side by side. At the north end of Section 45 there is a beautiful example of Roman funerary art, three sarcophaguses built around a Corinthian memorial column. The Arthur Jordan monument at the northeast corner of Section 25 is a lovely ornate circular columnar canopy. The Severin Mausoleum, (Sec.14) north across the road from the Eli Lily mausoleum, with its many classical features and decorative details, is one of the best for those studying architecture to take a close look at.
Romanesque
Some cemeteries have rows of Romanesque mausoleums,
distinct with their massive scale, squared-off surfaces, rounded arches,
and rusticated (rough hewn) stonework. Crown Hill has but a few prime
examples, the most typical being that of the Fitzgerald Mausoleum, the
second mausoleum southeast of the Hendricks' obelisk across from the Gothic
Chapel.
Gothic Characterized by pointed arches, and structures whose purpose seems to be height and light, some found that, in contrast to classical influences, "the Gothic style should be recommended as being the most expressive of the Christian's hope." A more modern author comments: "The poetic spirit of the characteristic heavenward gestures made this style appropriate for funerary images in ways in which the earlier Romanesque style, heavy and cubic, was not. ... Gothic, with its origins in churches, has been seen as the 'architecture of Christianity', a style whose 'lofty vaults and arches ...seem to resound with the choral hymns of angels."
In the cemetery, architecture was rarely a pure Gothic style, but often combined with classical figures and columns. Its ornateness made it very expensive. This may be the reason why the best examples of the Gothic influence at Crown Hill are public structures, the Gothic Chapel and the 34th Street Gate, both examples of the Gothic revival style.
Egyptian
Egyptian architecture has long had an influence on
monuments, possibly because many of the most famous examples of it, such as
the pyramids, were built as tombs. The Napoleonic expeditions to Egypt
around 1800 renewed interest in this style, as did the completion of the
Washington monument, an Egyptian obelisk, in 1884. The obelisk is the most
common example, especially at Crown Hill, but pyramids, pylons, battered
walls (thick at the base with an incline toward the top), and cavetto
cornices (concave), and columns with papyrus capitals, are represented
throughout many cemeteries. The C.B. Smith (Sec.5), the George Marrot
(Sec. 51), and the Carl Fisher (Sec 13), mausoleums all show varying
degrees of this influence.
Modern Art
As America arose from the 19th
century, it became more and more willing to express its own tastes in
architecture, such as those developed in Chicago by Louis Sullivan, whose
mausoleum for the Getty Family at Chicago's Graceland Cemetery, is said to
"mark the beginning of modern architecture in America." (This is announced
by a plaque in front of the mausoleum.) Many of Crown Hill's later
mausoleums, built after the 1920s, depart from the old influences and
reflect the new. The Dollman Mausoleum, at the northeast corner of Section
46, is an example with an art deco flavor. The nearby Askren monument is
perhaps a modern interpretation of a Gothic spire.
Suggested
Activities
1) Have the students draw their favorite monument. Herron Art
School Classes come to the cemetery occasionally and spend several hours
here drawing. Perhaps you could arrange
a similar activity.
2) Have the
students design a monument or a mausoleum. Which style of architecture
appeals to them the most? Which symbols would they most like to use on a
monument?
3) Students studying architecture could include a tour of
downtown to see which kinds of influences they can find. Getting out of
the bus and walking around will allow you to see much more detail, such as
the biplanes on panels in the Test Building on the southwest quadrant of
the Circle.
4) A tour of downtown should include a look at the statues.
At least four residents of Crown Hill are represented: Benjamin Harrison
at University Square, James Whitcomb on the Circle, and Oliver Morton and
Thomas Hendricks at the State Capitol.
5) Crown Hill has a photo contest
every year or two. Encourage those students interested in photography to
bring a camera and take pictures of the cemetery.
|
Web Design by FuneralNet Copyright © 1999, Crown Hill Cemetery & Funeral Home and FuneralNet |